Are We Making Disciples or Just Drawing a Crowd?

Are We Making Disciples or Just Drawing A Crowd?

In this episode, Jeff Hoglen challenges church leaders and pastors to rethink how they evaluate success. Instead of focusing solely on attendance and social media reach, he urges us to prioritize genuine spiritual transformation and discipleship.

Key topics:

The difference between gathering crowds and forming a church
Why size does not equate to health or spiritual growth
The limitations of traditional church metrics like attendance and giving
How to shift from consumer-focused to discipleship-centered systems
The importance of authentic community, accountability, and follow-up
Leaders' role in disrupting the crowd mentality for deeper spiritual impact
Practical steps to assess whether your church is truly making disciples
The cost and necessity of challenging church culture to prioritize transformation

Timestamps:

00:00 - Rethinking church metrics: From attendance to transformation

00:42 - Filling rooms vs. filling lives: What's the real goal?

01:42 - Size isn't everything: The difference between crowd and church health

02:10 - Attraction vs. mission: How churches form around consumerism or covenant

03:08 - The necessity of real discipleship beyond Sunday service

03:36 - Understanding true metrics: From attendance to spiritual change

04:06 - The findings of the Willow Creek Reveal study on spiritual growth

05:22 - Are people actually growing in their faith? Asking the tough questions

06:19 - Entertainment vs. investment: Building devoted disciples

07:50 - The early church’s focus on community and devotion over production

08:47 - The leadership challenge: Disappointing some for long-term growth

09:38 - Systematic follow-up and accountability as keys to transformation

10:52 - The importance of intentionality over performance

11:04 - Holding the line and aligning church practices with the mission

11:45 - Reflecting on the true measure: How many are being formed, not just present

12:15 - Action step: Have honest conversations about discipleship before next week's attendance report

Resources & Links:

Connect with Jeff Hoglen:

Game plan